Johnny's Jamaica Mistake Dressing, 32 Fl. Oz

I discovered Jamaica Mistake at Costco in the 2000's. Then it was discontinued for some reason, so I ordered it directly from the manufacturer. This is the perfect salad dressing but also I use it for egg salad, macaroni salad and all sorts of dishes/side dishes where one uses mayonnaise. It's also a great dipping sauce. If you like creamy Italian dressing, I'd recommend trying Jamaica Mistake!

I make cobb salads and use this dressing on it. It's really really good. I felt it was pricey, I bought it and paid the price because I could not find it anywhere else.

Jamaica mistake is the absolute yummiest to use in pasta salad. We do rainbow spiral noodles, mozzarella cubes, sliced black olives, diced cucumber, diced red bell peppers, and cherry tomatoes. Delicious!!

I loved it and everyone ! I let try it loved it! Absolutely delicious ! Thanks

There are so many ways you can use this dressing. It's good as a salad dressing. In this pandemic time I've kept a lot of frozen veggies like broccoli and I've put a Tbsp on them to to give them more flavor. We have lots of cherry tomatoes and I sliced them and used this on them with a few cucumbers. It's a good dip too. Only have one complaint. It is a giant bottle and I have trouble pouring and holding on to it. Maybe there is a smaller version. It just wasn't available when I bought this.

I can't find this item in local grocery stores so I was so glad to find one for a reasonable price on Amazon. Great on any salad but especially Cobb salad.

I love this as a salad dressing and a marinade. The only thing i dislike is that Amazon sell this item twice as much than the manufacturer.

My daughter puts this on EVERYTHING. Spaghetti? Check. Steak? Check. Chicken, tofu, salad? check. check. check. They don't sell it at every grocery store so I bought this GIANT bottle. It will last about a month. It thinner than ranch...more sweet than savory. I tried honey poppy seed instead - she hated it. It has to be Jamaica Mistake or nothing.