American Dream Nut Butter – Gluten-Free Chipwrecked Peanut Butter

Base: This peanut butter is one of my favorites from American Dream. The texture is not as drizzly as some of the other PBs. It is soft, smooth, and spreads nicely, and almost drippy. It has a rich buttery flavor. It is not tart like NY style cheesecake but instead sweeter like a no-bake cheesecake. The richness of the peanut butter is a great juxtaposition to the sweetness of the cheesecake. There is just enough chocolate to balance the flavors.Toppings: The grainy crunch of the crust mix in is like a no-bake bottom layer of cheesecake with almost a buttery popcorn flavor (in a good way). The toppings are easily mixable, but each time it needs to be stirred back in as they tend to sink. There is a lot of great texture to this butter.Rating: 9.5/10Sweetness: Semi-sweetComments: I can only imagine this PB is one of those you’ll like a lot or not at all. I really love it, but it’s intense .. so, be ready for that! Overall there are so many layers of flavor in this PB; it is deep and rich/warm and cozy. Great melted; great cold. It’s maybe not as versatile because of the many flavors in the butter— that can be a good thing or not, depending on what you want it for 🙂

Yummy. Now I want to try the others!

Good stuff! But both peanut and almond have the stevia twang after eating. But do prefer peanut butter version over almond. But I understand some can’t each peanuts with allergies. Check them out, they are good.

Tasted really good not too thick or too thin would buy again

I ordered the Double Butter and Cinnamon coffee cake. I understand the disclaimer about higher fat peanut butter and chocolate melting but neither of these had any add ins. Both were thin, runny. I stirred well. Both were jars of thin peanut butter. The Cinnamon coffee cake did taste like cinnamon.No refund or replacement after contacting customer service.I had the same flavors previously and they were loaded with add ins.I just paid over $30 for 2 small jars of thin peanut butter.Just a suggestion, why don’t you keep add ins separate to be stirred in later or pack with some dry ice if shipping to warm climates melt the product.

Love, love, love the American dream, peanut butter, all of it!

These products taste very good, but only one arrived to me as pictured with the crunchy toppings. The rest had varying consistencies.

I have ordered from American Dream before and loved everything I have gotten so far. This is my 4th jar- first time trying this flavor. I was very disappointed once I opened it. Unfortunately it didn’t have the candy mix as advertised it is just plain peanut butter. Maybe this was just a bad batch or I got the end of a batch not sure. With the cost I expect a good product as advertised. I will order from them again as this hasn’t been my previous experiences. Hopefully it’s a fluke.