Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Eye Liner, Matte, Waterproof, Easy to draw, Smudgeproof, Longwear Formula, Smart Tip Brush, No Mess Application, Black 12g

I've used this eyeliner for years. It's the only cheaper eyeliner I've found that doesn't crumble after a while. I've fallen asleep in this before and it's stayed on. Great product. Easy to apply and very black

Only use this product and I just love it.

I'm hopeless with make up. But this is so easy to use and doesn't smudge. Will deffo buy again. Price is good too.

Good value for money. This liner goes on smoothly and is easily controlled, thick or thin. It does take a few seconds to dry, so you must be patient and not blink too quickly. But once it dries, it stays put. Note this is the waterproof model. In practice, it is certainly run/smudge proof. It is more water resistant than water proof (rain okay, swimming not really), but merely comes off rather than leaving dark smudges. I find it a good everyday liner. Do read the label and get the right one, though, as the same model that is not labelled waterproof will leave you with smudges after a few hours.

I love this liner. Goes on really easy and lasts all day. It's waterproof and matte. It's perfect

This eyeliner is long lasting waterproof and smudge proof. It goes on easily and is a lovely shiny black.

Only liquid liners that works for me consistently with a nice fine tip for sharp eye liner!

It's good, but it doesn't survive very teary eyes. Also, sometimes it leaves a tingling sensation in the upper eyelids a little, not on every application though and I don't even have very sensitive skin.