Beauty Spot 12 Colors Retractable Waterproof Lip Liner Set, Roll It Up Auto Lip Liner Pencil, Long Lasting Fade Resistant

For the price there are great. They apply just as smooth as a department lip liner. Very nice. Colors off a little bit as shown on outside, for the price it’s ok.

Product is as described. Nice smooth application. Colors are nice. Good product. I will buy again.

This product is a great value. The order included a wide range of colors to choose from. Lip liners are highly pigmented and go on very easily. The color swatches do not actually match the colors of the pencils— the colors are lighter. The only issue I have is none of the colors really suit me.

Nina Pool recommended. I didn’t care for all of the colors - but that was the beauty of this pack - I got to try on many shades and with the ones that I kept - it was still good deal.Stays on for a good amount of time.Def recommend.

The colors where it what was marked in the tube. Not even close. Don’t buy!!!

I would do a swatch test but that would take too much time lol. Just know if you’re buying this based off of the colors on the liners, that’s not the color you’ll get when you use them. They’re pretty similar in color to eachother and hard to differentiate between them all. Don’t get me wrong, the pigment is good and they go on smooth, last a decent amount of time, and come off clean…. but like i said the colors are not as pictured/described at all. Do with this what you will

The color range was not similar to the colors on the package. Many were the same color.

This product comes in a nice array of colors and this cream pencil moves really well when you apply it. It does not smear easily.