ETUDE Proof 10 Gel Pencil Liner, Eyeliner with Wearable Shades, Sharpenable Tip, Creamy Gel Texture, Waterproof & Sebum-Proof Precision Liner, Korean Makeup, Beauty, Black (0.011 Ounce)

I'm always on the quest for the perfect bronze eyeliner - the color bronze of the eyeliner is perfection. Not gold, not black, just a perfect bronze. It lasts all day and the color doesn't change. I've tried more expensive bronze liners that I loved...but those were discontinued. This liner is just as good as the Mally Penny, Marc Jacobs Bronze, Tarte Bronze - but at a fraction of the price. I love it!

This has been my go to eyeliner for a couple of years now. I like that it does not smear. It is dry going on - not as smooth as some, but I think that is what keeps it from smearing.

One of my favorite gel eyeliners. Affordable, glides on easily, and color intensity is nice. It does smudge a bit on the under eye for me but most eyeliners do that with my eyes.

This bleeds and run. Product is not long lasting.

Puts L’Oréal, Madeline, Mary Kay, cover girl 24 hour eye liner to shame! I have looked for one to last all day long and this one works!

I’ve been getting this eyebrow pencil in brown for years. The shape of the pencil and retractable feature is simply perfect. It lasts me a long time! Light strokes to fill my brows make it look so natural. My brows are always on fleek, thanks to these!

I had high expectations for this pencil because I have other products from this brand which I really like. This pencil was disappointing. The whole led came sliding down the tube of the pencil and the product was at most about 4 inches. I am returning because this is really bad quality. I can’t even say if the pencil’s formula is decent because the product itself it’s such bad quality. It came broken, maybe it was just the pencil I received but it’s too much of a hassle to reorder a new one just to find out it’s quality control issue. Will not be repurchasing.

Very good product and quality. Like it a lot

にじまず、使い勝手良い！

芯の硬さもちょうどいいです。柔らかすぎてもベタつくし硬いと痛いしこちらは安いしどうかなと不安でしたが満足です。今まではイミュのジェルアイライナーでしたが値段の割にあっという間に無くなるのでこちらを試しました。使用感はほぼ同じです。どちらが柔らかいかと言えばイミュですがかえってこのくらいの方が加減が出来て良いです。と言ってもストレスなく痛くなくスルッと描けるしパンダ目にもなりません。あとはどのくらいの量なのか、ですね。 でも値段はイミュの3分の2くらいなのでいつ無くなるか心配せずに使えます。

簡単に言って最高です。 全然よれない、落ちない✨ 汗で下まぶたが黒くなりがちでしたが、こちらのアイライナーは落ちません！ びっくりしました。 ただ、太めなので細くラインを入れるのには向いてないですね。 囲みとかが好きな人は使いやすいと思います。

滑らかで良いんですが、ちょっと芯が太すぎる感じです。

Love it long lasting