Too Faced Killer Liner Waterproof Gel Eyeliner - Black

Best eyeliner ever! It doesn’t smudge and last all day just like you put it on! I’m in love this by far is the best eyeliner I have used!!

This is the best eyeliner for the wet line at your lashes. Easy to sharpen & comes with a sharpener.

The pencil worked great at first. It is difficult to sharpen and breaks off leaving a sharp wooden edge. It does not stay longer than a few hours and smears.

Long lasting on waterline. However took a star bcz it ends up in the corners of my eyes and slightly bleeds underneath my eyes. That being said, I buy it again and again. I'm 57 and no one tells you what happens when you get old. The texture of you face and especially your eyes changes tremendously. If you smoke, STOP! This has stood up to my long days better than most so I truly recommend it

Update: This is not the eyeliner that I've used in the past. I didn't realize it was now a pencil enclosed in plastic, making it almost impossible to sharpen. Also, it dries out quickly and flakes off onto my face. For me, this is a waste of money. I use the black eyeliner, and like that the ingredients are safer than most other eyeliners out there, but unfortunately it doesn't last very long. If I apply it in the morning, by the afternoon the liner has dissolved a bit, leaving only a very thin line. Also, it's not a smooth application, sort of pulls on my eyelid and takes a while to build. Will keep using until I can find another safe alternative.