Vasanti Kajal Extreme - Charcoal Brown Eyeliner Pencil with Built in Smudger (Waterproof, Paraben Free)

Easy application and stays put above my upper eyelashes but I found it melts at the outer corners of my eyes after an hour or so but that's always been a problem. I made the mistake of trying it on my waterline, big mistake as my eyes looked sore and red within the hour.

This eye pencil goes on more easily than I'm used to , but it was also hard to remove at the end of the day! The small parcel took me ages to unwrap - couldn't there be a better way of doing it? However, I may well continue to use it.

It's extreme alright! You get a strong look, but unfortunately I cannot smudge it with the smudger as I want to in order to soften the look because, either the smudger is too hard, or the eyeliner has set before I have a chance to smudge it. So I'm left with quite a harsh look. If you want a really strong appearance to your eyeliner it will do.

My eyes. Beautiful and stays on all day

It's ok but rather pricey cheaper ones are as good

Eyeliner fine but sharpner very hard to use. Had to get my daughter to do it for 2

I liked this when first received it, I then tried to sharpen it and has never been same since

Bad experience with that.