Across the Spectrum: Understanding Issues in Evangelical Theology

I have read through this book once and fully intend to read it again soon. The authors cover many of the main theological issues facing the church. I found the approach of the authors to be refreshingly objective. In fact, I honestly can't remember reading a book that manages to give both sides to argument in such a rational and objective way.The authors have managed to cover so many different topics that there is, of course, a limit to the depth to which each topic can be covered. If you feel passionate about a particular view point, then you may feel that the argument supporting that view wasn't sufficiently strong. I was certainly left wanting more at the end of each chapter. However, the book would have to be way longer, or only cover half the subjects, if a more in-depth approach was taken. However, it would be unfair to suggest that the book was light on content, theology or rational arguments, because it isn't. It packs a surprising amount of content into each chapter using scripture, church history, and reasoning to explain each side, or sides, of the debate.It hasn't changed any of my main views, but it has helped to open my mind. I am sure the same would be true for those of opposing viewpoints. However, it has helped me to understand why people believe otherwise and the reasoning behind their convictions. In some cases it has strengthened what I believe, and in other cases it has helped me to understand that the opposing viewpoints should at least be given some consideration. The book has the potential to help Christians of different theological persuasions to communicate in a more reasoned manner.If you are overly dogmatic, then you will not enjoy reading this book. I personally found it very enjoyable and would recommend it to any Christian seeking a better understanding of what they believe and why.

This book definitely deserves five stars! I have friends who are entrenched in certain theological viewpoints because it is the view point that their favorite pastor or a podcastor takes. I don’t want to decide this way. Instead, I want to thoughtfully and prayerfully consider well-reasoned arguments on both sides. This book has helped tremendously. It lays out well-reasoned arguments on both sides and offers well-reasoned responses to the common objections to the arguments. It has forced me to think. Even though such thinking is not always comfortable, it is essential to spiritual growth. Plus, I have children who are approaching their teenage years and I want to have a firm understanding of what I believe, what I don’t believe, and what I admittedly am not sure about (but am at least informed about) so that I am prepared to counsel and engage with them as they face these questions . Again, this book is helping with that.

I appreciate the approach to disputed theological issues that provides an explanation of the various views associated with the issue and the biblical reasoning for those views. That is what is provided in "Across the Spectrum". Boyd and Eddy address a number of important areas where Evangelical Christians disagree, e.g., The Inspiration Debate; The Foreknowledge Debate; The Sanctification Debate; The Destiny of the Unevangelized Debate; The Charismatic Gifts Debate; and many others. These authors definitely jumped head-first into some very real and passionately argued subjects.When Boyd and Eddy address a viewpoint they provide the biblical argument for the position; as well as supporting arguments; and a response to the typical objections for the position. I got the impression that they did not intentionally shortchange a viewpoint. In their defense of each position, they made a genuine attempt to provide a compelling and convincing argument. In fact, occasionally, I agreed with all the points of view that were presented regarding an issue. In those cases, it was helpful to read an "Archie" comic book and then lay down for a while to regain my mental equilibrium.For many years, I've heard Christians defend a particular theological point of view with an attitude that suggested: "It's impossible for any thinking, rational, biblically sincere person to arrive at any position on this matter other than the one I'm explaining." That bothers me. It's fine to be sincere and it's fine to be firmly convinced. But it seems to me that it can be intellectually dishonest to look at a theological issue that has been debated by brilliant minds for centuries without resolution--for example Predestination vs. Free Will--and suggest that your viewpoint is obviously the only conclusion that any true Christian could possibly reach.A book like "Across the Spectrum" is very helpful to someone like me who would like to try to understand the various positions and why they are held.

A very useful resource for hearing and understanding a wide variety of Christian views on doctrine. There were opinions that even I, as a seminary student, was unaware of. Strengths and weaknesses are also given for each position. Practically speaking, it helps one respect views of other Christians that are different, which should reduce tension and polemical rhetoric that causes division in the body of Christ. The historical diversity of Christianity should be recognized and embraced over against strict dogmatism across the board, and this book reveals the many gray areas that all honest theologians acknowledge. I recommend this book for those with integrity and who are driven in seeking the truth of Scripture.

This is an excellent book for anyone who wants to see the various sides of Christian Doctrine within the evangelical tradition. While the book does not delve into some of the more liberal or fringe theological perspectives, it does a great job defining the views that are held by the majority of Christians throughout the years, particularly those within the Calvinistic and Armenian/Wesleyan Traditions. It is easy to read and formatted so that it can be used as a resource book for pastors, teachers, or those curious about different views.

I gave my first book to our youth pastor, after discussing it with youth and young adults several times. Has to buy another copy as it is a great go to to refresh on the differences in Christian beliefs and practices.

Boyd and Eddy present most issues that are divide evangelicals in a postitive and practical way. They don't take sides but leave that to the reader. If every Christian knew this book, the world would be a better place.

A really useful and worthwhile book. The authors have really cracked writing varying views without giving away which is theirs. A must for students of Christian doctrines and a useful tool for Pastors & preachers. Greg Boyd does it agin!

The negative reviews here express EXACTLY why this book is needed. Some people apparently think that their views are the only ones that should be allowed. Until you can show that you yourself are perfect, there is always the potential to be wrong.

Good book presents a fair cross section of arguments for and against different theological stances on a selection of issues of interest to evangelicals. Good for group study