Honest BeautyVibeliner Pencil Eyeliner | Electric (Matte Plum) | With Jojoba Oil, Meadowfoam Oil, & Macadamia Nut Oil | With built-in smudger | .038 Oz

Looking for eyeliner that is allergenic free and this one came up in the search. It had many positive reviews so I gave it a try.I have NO idea why this eyeliner scored so many stars! 10 minutes after applying I had "half moons" on my eyelids from the eyeliner transferring! It was nearly gone within half an hour and I hadn't yet stepped out into the Florida heat and humidity.This eyeliner is going into the trash! Waste of money!!!!

I’ve been using mac eye pencil for ages, but the color I had (duck) is no longer produced. So I’ve been looking for a new one to replace my favorite. As I wanted to use cruelty free make up, I found this one and I love it. I got the harmony color, I was hoping for more brown but that’s my fault. Harmony is more like bronze and lighter than I hoped but the pencil is soft and very light. I also like that little brush thingy at the back of it, it helps make it look more natural. I’ll get brown matte also.

Finding cosmetics that are free of things you don't want on your skin is challenging. This eyeliner accomplishes that fairly well. It isn't completely smear proof but it does apply easily and brown is a good choice for those who do not like a harsh line of black. I am mostly using it to "tightline" and to line from under my lashes and it does that job well.

I have sensitive skin & combination skin type and prone to irritation or breakouts. Unfortunately the product ingredients are clean the eyeliner smudged & smeared like crazy. I would say if you're just a tad oily it might work for you but I wouldn't waste your money.

Does not stay sharp, soft tip that breaks easily... Will not buy again.