Full description not available
R**W
Great analysis!
Musashi’s Book of Five Rings is a classic and read throughout the world. The Dokkodo is not as well known and is but a list of Musashi’s codes that he lived by. Musashi is not known for going into great detail. Often he would end a chapter with “you must research this”. The experts enlisted in this endeavor bring a fresh perspective on Musashi’s code and a new line of thinking on the man himself. Was Musashi a sociopath? Maybe. You can make that case…But it’s hard to measure a man who lived 500 years ago in a land full of razor sharp swords by applying today’s standards. I enjoyed this book immensely and recommend it, especially to those interested in Musashi.
R**I
Unique Perspectives on Samurai Precepts
Full Disclosure: I received a free, autographed copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. And yes, with these authors honest is a very real part of the requirement. It's part of why I follow them and devour their publications when I find them.This is an interpretation of the original precepts from Miyamoto Musashi. The precepts are taken one by one and interpreted from several viewpoints, that of a monk, a businessman, an insurance adjuster, a warrior, and a teacher, though not actually in that order. The combination of perspectives is very illuminating and triggered my brain into deep thought for each of the precepts. Which also meant that once I read a chapter I had to put the book down and ruminate upon it for a while before moving to the next precept. How long varied by precept. I learned new things from each precept and each of the interpretations of them. Musashi was, by modern sensibilities, very much a functional psychopath. That doesn't mean, as is alarmingly the assumption these days, that everything about him should be wiped from history. Quite the opposite, as we can learn from him, who he was, and what he did. That doesn't mean we aim to become pyschos or even remotely risk becoming pyschos. It means we can use what he did and what he taught to make ourselves better, and the immediate comparisons offered up by the combinations of perspectives in this book are extremely useful for doing that.
D**S
Good Read
This was a very good book to read and the different perspectives really help to understand it.
A**R
Musashi for the 21st century
They take a precept of Musashi and have 4 or 5 different types of modern interpretations of his work by various professional people .The time span and historical differences between Musashi's day and today may be too wide to overcome.
D**D
Totally recommendable!
I dig how this is formatted. Each of Musashi's rules is analyzed from five different points of view; each perspective has it's unique list of pros and cons. The debate is not so much tempered as it is informative. It's a very enlightening way to discuss any philosophy I think, and I got a lot from reading this.
P**Z
Less than 1% of the book is Musashi's actual words
The 21 precepts below are the ONLY words actually written by Musashi in this 220+ page book. The rest is five people giving their opinion on each precept. Save yourself the time and the money.precept 1. Accept everything just the way it is.precept 2. Do not seek pleasure for it's own sake.precept 3. Do not, under any circumstances, depend on a partial feelingprecept 4. Think lightly of yourself and deeply of the worldprecept 5. Be detached from desire your whole lifeprecept 6. Do not regret what you have doneprecept 7. Never be jealousprecept 8. Never let yourself be saddened by a seperationprecept 9. Resentment and complain are appropriate neither for oneself or othersprecept 10. Dont let yourself be guided by the feeling of love or lustprecept 11. In all things, have no preferenceprecept 12. Be indifferent to where you liveprecept 13. Do not pursue the taste of good foodprecept 14. Do not hold on to possessions you no longer needprecept 15. Do not act following customary beliefsprecept 16. Do not collect weapons or practice with weapons beyond what is usefulprecept 17. Do not fear deathprecept 18. Do not seek to possess either goods or fiefs for your old ageprecept 19. Respect Buddha and the gods without counting on their helpprecept 20.You may abandon your own body but you must preserve your honorprecept 21. Never stray from the way
A**R
Good Precepts, not the best commentary
Bought the book because I am a Musashi addict. Not a terrible read, but nothing super insightful in the commentary. The book has 5 people respond how they feel about the precepts. The individuals were supposed to use their field of expertise to comment on the precept: Monk, Warrior, Teacher, insurance agent, businessman. The only people who actually followed their specific field of interest were the Warrior and the Businessman. The Warrior had the best insights and seemed to grasp what the precepts were really about. The businessman was very informative taking the precept to the business world. The other 3 perspectives were nothing I enjoyed. The insurance agent was the only female perspective and she couldnt stop bringing up her husband in every comment…very annoying because she was supposed to be commenting from an insurance agents perspective, not a wife. Her title would have been better listed as “Wife” because she didn’t talk about the insurance world hardly at all. The other two perspectives were similar, more focused on personal ideas instead of the field they were supposed to be commenting on. The monk isn’t a Buddhist monk, he’s some sort of apostolic Christian monk? No idea because he never made it clear in the book what kind of monk he is and didn’t even take perspectives from a monks view…just another personal perspective. And lastly the teacher, he made a comment on food saying that “food is not medicine” , which can’t be farther from the truth, but some of his perspectives weren’t bad but not insightful. Would have loved to have someones perspective from Japan, or another country other than the US. Overall if you do buy it, definitely read the Warrior and businessman…the most insightful by far!
Trustpilot
1 day ago
2 weeks ago