2 PCS Windproof Ashtray with Lid, Newness Stainless Steel Modern Tabletop Ashtray for Outdoor or Indoor Use, Desktop Smoking Ash Tray for Home Office Decoration

They were actually much bigger than I anticipated (yes I know dimensions are listed, but despite many good and bad surprises upon arrival, this is apparently how I live on the edge - by not looking). I am happy with purchase. They do what I need. One actually turned into a change container and the other is used for intended purpose. Both are great.

Works as described but I wish there was a way to lock lid closed. Other than that I put a bit of sand in the bottom to weigh it down and it works to keep nasty butts and ashes out of sight.

Great idea, poor design. Unless you have a small flat-head screwdriver to assist you getting the top of to clean, you can't get the lid off. At the least, they need to have a screw on/off lid.

Just a little small

I liked them for a while. Then the weld holding the top on one of them gave way.

These are great outdoor ashtrays the wind doesn't blow the ashes all over the place. You can put out your cigarette and c lose the lid, put feet, I get compliments from all my smoking friends and some non-smokers as well.

These are really nice. I only gave it 4 stars because they aren't very heavy and if it had a seal on the small lid opening it would help keep water from getting inside when it rains.

Excellent quality! Love the size and ease

Easy to use amd clean