Men's Verdict

The boots were delivered promptly and are exceptionally comfortable, fitting true to size.

This is the THIRD time I’ve purchased these boots! They are excellent! I purchased my previous pair in 2016, and they lasted until earlier this year, 2025! The first pair lasted a long time, too. Now, I’m not putting them through the rigor of a daily construction job. I wear them for weekend yard work in the spring and fall. I wear them during the winter while blowing and shoveling snow. And I often wear them to wash and detail cars, so they get exposed to plenty of moisture, and the waterproofing works well. From a residential/consumer standpoint, they are getting used hard, and they’ve held up well. Finally, you just can’t beat the price. I paid $70 on sale. Go price-check work boots. You just can’t beat these boots for quality, value — and excellent durability. Highly Recommend!

This is probably my 4th or 5th pair of these boots. I beat the crap out of them and they take it in strides! Comfortable, durable and stylish.

Skechers Men’s Sargeants-Verdict Waterproof Boot Review These Skechers Verdict boots deliver on the basics — sturdy waterproof leather, thick lug soles, and that classic “work boot” look that works equally well on job sites or casual weekends. The **air-cooled memory foam** insole helps with comfort for all-day wear, though several reviewers mention it can flatten with time or benefit from aftermarket insoles. Fit is **true-to-size to slightly snug**, especially in regular width, so going up half a size (or ordering wide) is a safe bet if you plan to wear thick socks. The **traction** is solid on wet pavement, dirt, and light snow, though they’re not meant for technical hiking or ice. Waterproofing holds up well in rain and puddles. Durability feedback is mixed — some users get 5–10 years of heavy use, while others see seam or sole separation within a year, likely depending on workload and environment. The boots do feel **a bit heavy**, but that’s expected for full-grain leather. For around $60–70, they offer real value: dependable, weatherproof, and comfortable after break-in, though not quite as refined or light as premium options like Timberland or Rockport. Bottom line: A rugged, budget-friendly waterproof boot that’s perfect for work, casual wear, and light outdoor use — just expect a short break-in and possible insole upgrade for all-day comfort.

I read the reviews and many people suggested to order this boot a half size larger. I took their advice and was glad I did. I typically wear a 10 regular so I ordered and 10 1/2 regular. The boots don't fit perfectly but they are close and I can accept a boot that is just a little big. Not to big for me to make a difference. The quality of the boot is very good. I wear these as an everyday boot to do all kinds of work at home and away. Great grip, sturdy insole, tough exterior and they look good. The only compliant is that I wish they would be about an inch higher at the ankle but that isn't that important. I've had the boots about a week and put them through my usual test and they passed after the first day. If the boot continues to please me they will most likely become my goto boot. I had been wearing boots made by Rockport which are comfortable and very good boots. But these boots are stiffer and offer more protection for my feet, are comfortable enough for everyday wear and look even better.

My wife and I were headed for a week long trip where I knew we would be doing a lot of walking. I wanted something practical but not too showy or to casual, I thought these fit the bill. I was a little worried ordering them so close to our trip where I wouldn't be able to break them in, but that wasn't an issue. Wore these through TSA and was not stopped, wore them all week outside and inside walking and my feet felt great, probably the best show I own now, in regard to foot support and comfort. I would buy these again.

boots are great. I bought these many times over the years , very comfortable, but what is good having prime membership and when you purchased it they say it will be he next day delivery. and now it going to be 4 days later

Nice boot but too inflexible, I had to return it

well made very comfy, durable , waterproof

Excellent product

Best and most comfortable boots I've ever bought. Literally feels like a high end pair of soft sneakers/runners.

Duras y resistentes, cómodas en el pie. Justo lo que quería, las volvería a comprar y tienen un excelente precio y muy buena calidad

Ich habe mir diese Stiefel gekauft, weil ich etwas Robustes und Bequemes für den Winter gesucht habe. Ich bin sehr zufrieden mit meinem Kauf, die Stiefel sind aus hochwertigem Leder gefertigt, wasserdicht (4std. Schneeschippen und nicht ein Tropfen ging durch) und haben eine gute Passform. Die Memory Foam-Innensohle ist super bequem und die Gummisohle bietet einen Top Grip auf rutschigen Untergründen. Die Stiefel sind gut verarbeitet und sehen hochwertig aus. Auch wenn die Stiefel in der Kategorie Arbeitsstiefel zu finden sind sollte darauf hingewiesen werden, dass sie keine Stahlkappe oder sonstigen Schutz bieten! Die Gummisohle ist zwar ziemlich dick, aber ich bezweifle, dass sie durchtrittsicher ist. Wer bequeme Winterstiefel sucht wird hier fündig.