Full description not available
S**N
Successful
Well done history of music in the recent mode, with less detail than older histories, but more of an interpretive frame.
D**1
Good. Book arrived as described and in good time. Will shop with again
Good. Book arrived as described and in good time. Will shop with again
D**D
Fantastic coverage of the Baroque Period
Difficult to read and it feels a little 'dry' at times but this is the best book I've read on the baroque period and is pretty comprehensive.
T**D
Thorough, solid textbook
Many have awaited this final volume in the new Norton Music History Series. Manfred Bukofzer's volume in the original series was written in 1947 - clearly, much has been discovered since then.Hill's text is designed to be for upper level music majors, as the writing can become quite dense. The book begins with an introduction of the social and political factors shaping Europe during the Baroque Era. Other chapters cover the birth of opera and monody, new genres of instrumental music, and other subjects, generally switching back in between France, Italy, England, and Germany (Spain and Portugal are also included in a chapter).Great aspects about Hill's book first. The scholarship is excellent, and is as thorough (if not more so) than any other Baroque textbook out there. His bibliographical notes at the end of the chapter (as in the other books from the series) are wonderfully helpful. The description on the Doctrine of the Affections is as clear and informative as I've ever seen. His brief explanation of dance steps and tempo descriptions reminds me of Leonard Ratner's book on topics and is an excellent resource. The optional Anthology can prove to be very helpful for teaching or illustrating Hill's explanations as well.Here are the things I think readers may not like as much, though I was not able to find many. The reading is dense and can be difficult to follow with interest at times, which is not surprising for a 500-page upper-level textbook. Of the books in the Norton Series, I found several other author's writings to be of much lighter prose than Hill's, including Hoppin's tome on Medieval music. Many others will argue over the relative weight of importance of some composers in the textbook (there are many second-tier Italian composers, and Bach only gets about 25 pages), but I believe that any professor worth his/her salt will be easily solve this difficulty by supplementing the text with a few other materials.Though I would not rank this book as the best in the series, I do think it is certainly an improvement from Bukofzer and Claude Palisca's Prentice Hall textbook (not bad, but much less thorough). Any upper-level course on Baroque music should consider adopting Hill's text and Anthology.
J**M
Good book
It is thick but not heavy.Throughly go through Baroque music.Should have this if you are a serious music major, esp. graduate student
C**S
Five Stars
Very informative, comprehensive, and enjoyable to read.
K**B
used book is great condition
This is a good overall book without going into too much detail. That is what I need for the class I am teaching.
A**R
Five Stars
Useful
Trustpilot
1 day ago
2 months ago