Beauty For RealHi-Def Mascara, Just Black - Set of 2 - Defining & Volumizing Lash Definer - Humidity & Smudge Proof - Micro Brush Ensures Versatile Application - 1.5 oz

I have sad, anemic eyelashes. I also am just not into the weird spider eyes that are popular now. I think that trend is way out of control and 9 times out of 10, it looks awful and unnatural. This mascara has the tiniest brush on the wand, but builds dramatic lashes that are super noticeable. I love this stuff. I have tossed my Lancôme, Esteè Lauder, and Bang! mascaras since this one is so good. It’s way cheaper than the designer stuff, too.

My new favorite mascara. I have tried everything and everything smudges. This stayed on my lashes and didn’t come off making me look like a I spent the night at the movies crying. Will definitely purchase again.2/3/18 update. After wearing for 2 weeks, the mascara ended up underneath my eyes, like all of the other mascaras. I loved it at first- but now not so much. I thought maybe because my eyes were watery that day (def not waterproof), but that wasn’t the case. I loved this at first, but now can’t use it because it ends up under my eyes.

I agree with the description of dramatic. It does make your eyelashes very dark. But smudge-proof? Definitely not. It takes a lot of practice to apply it without getting it everywhere because it is a very "wet" mascara. (Which can be good if you need to take longer to work your lashes into submission.) I don't think it gives much more length or thickness than most mascaras. In fact the type of brush makes it a little bit more difficult to add length to my smaller lashes. This might change once I work with it some more. A little disappointed because of all of the great reviews. Wouldn't buy it again unfortunately.

I use a metal eyelash comb in between layers to separate my lashes and remove the clumps. This formula is very wet and somewhat viscous. Therefore, the brush doesn’t separate lashes very well during application and leaves some clumps behind. Luckily, the mascara doesn’t dry really fast so combing it all out works really well.This mascara also runs really easily. If I foresee the need for staying power in my mascara I don’t use this one, which I don’t mind. This mascara certainly isn’t advertised as waterproof.All in all, this is a 5 star mascara to me. I love the length and volume I get out of it. I especially love the intensity of the black.

I have sensitive eyes, and had given up on wearing non-waterproof mascara. I didn’t like the way waterproof mascara made my lashes look though. I got this first from Ipsy, and LOVED the way my lashes look long and thick, but this stays on and does not irritate my eyes! I’m sold on this!

After years of searching for a good, affordable mascara, I have found the one. I originally purchased elsewhere and loved so much that I now subscribe to it. 1. Does not clump 2. Lengthens lashes 3. Adds volume 4. Does not bleed off during day 5. Waterproof 6. Good price. I’m used to buying drugstore-priced mascara and this is a few dollars more. Totally worth it. It is not easy to remove - which is probably why it lasts all day.

A colleague posted on our FB page about this and aftyer seeing her fab lashes I went ahead and ordered 2, and it clearly didn't dissapoint. The brush is minuscule but it does a great job. Mascara glides nicely and separates and lengthens lashes big time. I take mine with a makeup cleaning toilette or just with water.It lasts my whole 13 hour day and I have even slept one day with it.I wear contact lenses and had no problems. Ordered the only color they had that was black. I'm extemely satisfied with this mascara.

I just used this morning and it's great mascara; but had to switch out an applicator from another product. The skinny teeth might work when the product is nearly gone; but with a new bottle it thickly covers the teeth and is not suitable to applying to lashes. I get the idea of applying to corners and small lashes; but design needs to support the full application and volume of product. Switching back and forth on applicators is a pain, so I suggest correcting this.